Fever BaseballFor collectors and stat nerdsFuture Value Radar (FVR) · On the record
Blue Notes · Umpire Grade2026-09-24

MIL @ PHI

Home plate: Dan Merzel

“The players kept asking for a second opinion — and kept getting one.”

B
Umpire Grade
92.0% accurate
0.8
Run Favor
runs, MIL
5
ABS Overturns
of 8 reviewed

What this shows — how Dan Merzel called the 175 pitches that were taken (no swing), graded against the tracked rulebook strike zone, or, on a pitch the ABS (Automated Ball-Strike System) reviewed on a challenge, against its ruling. 161 were right. Below, only the misses are plotted, alongside every challenged pitch.

The zone, as he called it

Challenge 1: J.T. Realmuto — the ump called it a ball, the robot ruled strike (OVERTURNED — ump overruled).1Challenge 2: Justin Crawford — the ump called it a strike, the robot ruled strike (upheld — ump confirmed).2Challenge 3: J.T. Realmuto — the ump called it a ball, the robot ruled strike (OVERTURNED — ump overruled).3Challenge 4: Gary Sánchez — the ump called it a strike, the robot ruled strike (upheld — ump confirmed).4Challenge 5: Alec Bohm — the ump called it a strike, the robot ruled ball (OVERTURNED — ump overruled).5Challenge 6: J.T. Realmuto — the ump called it a ball, the robot ruled strike (OVERTURNED — ump overruled).6Challenge 7: Garrett Mitchell — the ump called it a strike, the robot ruled strike (upheld — ump confirmed).7Challenge 8: J.T. Realmuto — the ump called it a strike, the robot ruled ball (OVERTURNED — ump overruled).8
strike called ballball called strikeABS overturnedABS upheld

The calls that moved the game

  1. 1+0.39▲7 · 2-2 strike called ball· challenged ✓
    Joey Ortiz vs Alex McFarlane
  2. 2+0.23▲8 · 0-2 strike called ball
    Sal Frelick vs Chase Shugart
  3. 3-0.21▲2 · 3-0 ball called strike
    Gary Sánchez vs Andrew Painter

Run impact from the count run-value table: a missed strike three is worth far more than one on 3-0.

ABS — the Automated Ball-Strike System

8 pitches went to the robots · 5 overturned (ump overruled) · 3 upheld (ump confirmed). This is the ABS system’s own measurement — Hawk-Eye optical ball-tracking, not our model.

  1. 1J.T. Realmuto — ump said ball, robot ruled strike: overturned.
  2. 2Justin Crawford — ump said strike, robot ruled strike: upheld.
  3. 3J.T. Realmuto — ump said ball, robot ruled strike: overturned.
  4. 4Gary Sánchez — ump said strike, robot ruled strike: upheld.
  5. 5Alec Bohm — ump said strike, robot ruled ball: overturned.
  6. 6J.T. Realmuto — ump said ball, robot ruled strike: overturned.
  7. 7Garrett Mitchell — ump said strike, robot ruled strike: upheld.
  8. 8J.T. Realmuto — ump said strike, robot ruled ball: overturned.

Our tracked-rulebook zone matched the ABS ruling on 8 of 8 — a zone-definition gap (ABS grades a standardized, height-based zone). Where the two disagree, the umpire is graded on the ABS ruling.

Paste the link anywhere — the card previews on its own. Or take it with you.

Post on X