Fever BaseballFor collectors and stat nerdsFuture Value Radar (FVR) · On the record
The collector market · as of

The Grading Desk

You are holding the raw card. Is it worth $79.99 to send it to PSA? That depends on how often this card comes back a 10 — so this board prints how often it would have to.

We do not know your odds, and we are not going to guess them. Whether a submission pays turns on the card’s gem rate — the share of copies that come back a 10 — and that lives in a population report we do not have. So we invert the question and give you the hurdle instead: the number beside each card is how often it must gem to break even. You bring the odds. Break-even assumes the card comes back a PSA 9 or a PSA 10. Real submissions come back 8 and below, and those losses are not in this number. It also counts only PSA's per-card fee — handling and return shipping are charged per submission and are not here. Both omissions push the same way: every figure on this page is the optimistic case.

487 cards priced and traded enough to rank (20+ sales) · 5 clear the fee even as a PSA 9 · 83 need the odds, median 54.3% · 399 no gem rate can save. Fee assumed: $79.99, PSA Regular, checked 2026-09-06 — the cheapest tier PSA is currently selling. Handling and return shipping are charged per submission and are not in it.

Waiting is part of the answer. PSA has not canceled its cheaper tiers, it paused them — PSA Value and the rest stopped taking submissions on 2026-06-02, with no reopening date announced. If they come back at $32.99, this same board reads very differently: 119 of these 487 cards would be beyond saving instead of 399, and 38 would clear the fee on a 9 instead of 5. That is historical context, not a price you can pay today.

Paid link — as an eBay Partner, FVR earns from qualifying purchases.

Clears the fee as a 9

The PSA 9 price alone covers the raw card and the fee. A 10 is the upside, not the requirement. Ranked by what a 10 would add.

1
Zack Wheeler
Zack Wheeler #AA-9
raw $199 · PSA 9 $425 · PSA 10 $676
pays as a 9
a 10 pays $397 over
Find this card →
2
Munetaka Murakami
Munetaka Murakami [Mojo] #9
raw $5.54 · PSA 9 $124 · PSA 10 $469
pays as a 9
a 10 pays $383 over
Find this card →
3
Esmerlyn Valdez
Esmerlyn Valdez #CPA-EV
raw $52.80 · PSA 9 $158 · PSA 10 $310
pays as a 9
a 10 pays $178 over
Find this card →
4
Andy Pages
Andy Pages #17
raw $2.44 · PSA 9 $146 · PSA 10 $175
pays as a 9
a 10 pays $92.57 over
Find this card →
5
Zack WheelerRC
Zack Wheeler #US50
raw $1.99 · PSA 9 $101 · PSA 10 $121
pays as a 9
a 10 pays $39.02 over
Find this card →

Lowest hurdle

These need a 10 to pay — but not often. Lowest break-even first; on this board smaller is better.

1
Mike TroutRC
Mike Trout #US175
raw $296 · PSA 9 $375 · PSA 10 $935
0.2% tens
a 10 pays $559 over
Find this card →
2
Salvador Perez
Salvador Perez #BCP124
raw $8.63 · PSA 9 $85.00 · PSA 10 $210
2.9% tens
a 10 pays $121 over
Find this card →
3
Eli WillitsRC
Eli Willits #BSPA-EW
raw $114 · PSA 9 $176 · PSA 10 $457
6.4% tens
a 10 pays $263 over
Find this card →
4
Eli Willits
Eli Willits #CPA-EW
raw $160 · PSA 9 $206 · PSA 10 $636
8.1% tens
a 10 pays $396 over
Find this card →
5
Shohei OhtaniRC
Shohei Ohtani #49
raw $90.42 · PSA 9 $137 · PSA 10 $550
8.1% tens
a 10 pays $380 over
Find this card →
6
Pete Crow-Armstrong
Pete Crow-Armstrong #177
raw $3.71 · PSA 9 $61.00 · PSA 10 $255
11.7% tens
a 10 pays $171 over
Find this card →
7
Ryan Sloan
Ryan Sloan #CPA-RS
raw $72.00 · PSA 9 $134 · PSA 10 $288
12% tens
a 10 pays $136 over
Find this card →
8
José Ramírez
Jose Ramirez #HA-27
raw $39.85 · PSA 9 $87.83 · PSA 10 $275
17.1% tens
a 10 pays $155 over
Find this card →
9
Kade Anderson
Kade Anderson #BDC-3
raw $2.99 · PSA 9 $64.32 · PSA 10 $170
17.7% tens
a 10 pays $87.02 over
Find this card →
10
Jacob MisiorowskiRC
Jacob Misiorowski #10
raw $2.27 · PSA 9 $34.46 · PSA 10 $298
18.2% tens
a 10 pays $215 over
Find this card →
11
Jacob Misiorowski
Jacob Misiorowski #BST-13
raw $4.10 · PSA 9 $54.00 · PSA 10 $203
20.3% tens
a 10 pays $118 over
Find this card →
12
Seiya Suzuki
Seiya Suzuki #HA-22
raw $48.37 · PSA 9 $85.00 · PSA 10 $290
21.2% tens
a 10 pays $162 over
Find this card →
13
Jarren Duran
Jarren Duran #HA-24
raw $31.50 · PSA 9 $69.94 · PSA 10 $250
23.1% tens
a 10 pays $139 over
Find this card →
14
Brett BatemanRC
Brett Bateman #CPA-BBA
raw $32.13 · PSA 9 $83.53 · PSA 10 $204
23.7% tens
a 10 pays $91.96 over
Find this card →
15
William Contreras
William Contreras #HA-30
raw $33.49 · PSA 9 $44.00 · PSA 10 $320
25.2% tens
a 10 pays $206 over
Find this card →
16
Juan Soto
Juan Soto #HA-32
raw $38.64 · PSA 9 $70.29 · PSA 10 $260
25.5% tens
a 10 pays $141 over
Find this card →
17
Ben RiceRC
Ben Rice #139
raw $2.99 · PSA 9 $40.00 · PSA 10 $204
26.2% tens
a 10 pays $121 over
Find this card →
18
Cooper IngleRC
Cooper Ingle #CDA-CI
raw $17.97 · PSA 9 $80.00 · PSA 10 $145
27.6% tens
a 10 pays $47.03 over
Find this card →
19
Cam Schlittler
Cam Schlittler [Mojo] #53
raw $3.27 · PSA 9 $33.00 · PSA 10 $200
30.1% tens
a 10 pays $117 over
Find this card →
20
Kyle SchwarberRC
Kyle Schwarber #66
raw $3.99 · PSA 9 $44.20 · PSA 10 $175
30.5% tens
a 10 pays $90.52 over
Find this card →
21
Aaron JudgeRC
Aaron Judge #32
raw $21.49 · PSA 9 $62.26 · PSA 10 $183
32.5% tens
a 10 pays $81.55 over
Find this card →
22
Freddie FreemanRC
Freddie Freeman #145
raw $15.00 · PSA 9 $52.76 · PSA 10 $178
33.7% tens
a 10 pays $83.01 over
Find this card →
23
Kenley JansenRC
Kenley Jansen #US-114
raw $7.95 · PSA 9 $38.00 · PSA 10 $180
35.1% tens
a 10 pays $92.47 over
Find this card →
24
Chandler Simpson
Chandler Simpson #HA-50
raw $25.00 · PSA 9 $58.19 · PSA 10 $189
35.9% tens
a 10 pays $83.76 over
Find this card →
25
Justin Wrobleski
Justin Wrobleski #CPA-JWR
raw $18.75 · PSA 9 $34.62 · PSA 10 $211
36.4% tens
a 10 pays $112 over
Find this card →

Prices are SportsCardsPro sold comps from FVR’s nightly archive, the same source as The Card Pulse. This page is about the economics of a submission, not about the player — the engine’s read on the man lives on the boards.