The Clock and the Crowd

The clock and the crowd

Nine days. That's what's left on call C0002, filed July 11, when we said Edouard Julien's results on contact would climb at least 30 points over his filing baseline by September 27. The crowd reads it the other way. Chatter from the last two weeks paints a hot streak: multi-hit games, a two-run double that a team account called the play of the game, a Quebec baseball writer noting a .324 average with eight RBI over nine September games. The chatter says he's heating up. The engine says not yet.

Our call doesn't grade on batting average. It grades on what the bat actually produced — the real value of contact, not park-adjusted, not dressed up. On that measure, 20 balls into the window, Julien has moved −0.026 away from the target. He needed to go up 30 points. He went down 26.

The person

Edouard Julien was born in Quebec City on April 30, 1999. His father, Remy, an Expos fan, put a glove in his hand at three or four years old. Later, when the swing needed work, they used a bat-speed app in the garage. Growing up with Team Canada, Julien swung so hard his helmet would fly off his head. His coach told him to ease up, just put the bat on the ball. He kept swinging hard.

He couldn't speak English when he arrived at Auburn. On his first day of practice, coaches yelled instructions and asked questions, and Julien answered yes to everything. They pointed where to go and he followed without knowing if it meant left field or something else. The Phillies drafted him in the 37th round in 2017; he didn't sign. Minnesota took him in the 18th round in 2019, pick 539, and paid him $493,000 after raising the offer. He won silver with Canada at the 2019 Pan American Games, tore his elbow, had Tommy John surgery. He was back. He starred in the 2023 World Baseball Classic. Back again.

He debuted April 12, 2023, and hit .263 with 16 homers and an .840 OPS as a rookie. Then the line went the wrong way: .199 in 2024, .220 in 2025, and now .208 with three home runs and minus-0.8 WAR across 88 games with Colorado this season. Minnesota let him go. The Rockies picked him up. The garage-built swing is still in there. The stat line has been bleeding for three years.

The signal

Julien ranks No. 2 of 20 on our breakout board. His EV95 is 105.57 mph across 164 balls in play. His park-adjusted luck gap is −0.1138 — results on contact running well below what the physics supports. That's the board's claim: the bat is owed.

But the call is a different job than the board. The board ranks on park-adjusted luck gap. The call resolves on actual value on contact — what the bat really produced — measured against the baseline frozen at filing: 0.3385, set through July 10. The target is 0.3685. The current reading is 0.3125. Twenty balls in play so far, and the engine won't put a grade on it until 25 — a scoreboard built on six swings is a slot machine. Remy Julien used a bat-speed app in the garage to build this swing. The engine doesn't grade bat speed — it grades what the bat does to a baseball.

The AAA hot streak is real in the box score. It just hasn't shown up in the metric we bet on.

The market

Julien's 2026 Topps Series 2 Gold #660 raw sits at $1.99 across 40 sales. His 2023 Bowman Chrome Prospects PSA 10 holds at $8.00, flat over the last week. Cardboard hasn't budged on the AAA surge — same as the engine, it's waiting for contact that pays.

Edouard Julien cards on eBay →

Paid link — as an eBay Partner, FVR earns from qualifying purchases. Not financial advice. We take positions only after publication — never before. Misses stay on the record.

On the record

Call C0002 resolves September 27. What proves us wrong: if Julien's actual value on contact finishes below 0.3685 — if the AAA hits don't translate into contact quality that clears the filing baseline by 30 points — the ledger reads MISS and it stays there forever. Nine days left, five more balls in play to reach the minimum. The crowd sees a man getting hot. The engine sees a bat that hasn't caught up. We'll know September 27.

---

Biographical details per Wikipedia, Auburn Tigers, theScore, and MLB.com. All performance data: MLB StatsAPI via the FVR engine.