The Buzz · November 10, 2026
The Buzz — Tuesday, November 10
Five names from the awards cycle and the open market, and under each, the number that says whether the take holds up.
Kevin McGonigle
The take Tigers' young infielder wins AL Rookie of the Year
The take is true, and the full-season sample is why. McGonigle went straight from prospect to everyday big-leaguer on Opening Day, debuted at 21 with four hits and two RBI, and never gave the job back. The slash line behind the award, .278/.376/.430 with an .806 OPS, describes a good on-base hitter with moderate power at a premium infield spot, not a slugger who carried the trophy on home runs. The BBWAA made it official Monday, and MLB.com's own finalists page confirms it. He was the best rookie in the American League from the first day of the season. The voters had a full year to see it, and they did.
Kevin McGonigle cards on eBay →(paid link)
Sal Stewart
The take Reds slugger Sal Stewart wins NL Rookie of the Year
32 home runs, 112 RBI, and the only Cincinnati rookie ever with a 30-homer, 100-RBI season. MLB.com calls him the 14th rookie in the majors to reach those numbers, and says each of the previous nine to do it since the award began in 1947 won Rookie of the Year. The BBWAA vote Monday confirmed what the Sporting News and the Players Choice Awards had already said. He led all NL rookies in home runs, RBIs, extra-base hits (57), and total bases (285), and he played all 162 games, the first rookie to do that since Delmon Young in 2007.
The Reds won 75 games and finished last in the Central. The award does not care. Stewart's season was his own, and his 164 hits were the most by a Reds rookie since Pete Rose's 170 in 1963.
Sal Stewart cards on eBay →(paid link)
Carson Benge
The take Benge was robbed; voters rewarded Stewart's RBIs over all-around play
The vote is over, and Benge lost. Stewart took 20 of 30 first-place votes and 170 points to Benge's seven and 107. Two voters ranked Benge as low as fifth, and those ballots stung, but they did not decide this. Stewart's lead was wider than any two votes could close.
The argument that lives is not about fairness. It is about what voters value. MLB.com framed the result as Stewart's traditional excellence, 32 home runs and 112 RBI, beating Benge's modern, analytical case. Benge became the first Mets rookie to steal 20 bases and hit 20 home runs, added 10 outfield assists as a right fielder, and finished with 4.3 bWAR. But bWAR did not even put Benge first among rookies. Wetherholt's 4.5 edged him, so the analytics case is not as clean as the crowd wants it to be.
The number that settles the anger is .828. Benge carried a .498 OPS into May 3, and from that morning on he produced an .828 OPS over his final 126 games. The slow start was real, and it ended. Voters may have weighed the first month, or they may have weighed Stewart's 112 RBIs more heavily than 20 homers, 22 steals, and a strong arm. Either way, this was a preference, not a robbery. Seven of 30 writers put Benge first. The other 20 saw something they liked more.
Carson Benge cards on eBay →(paid link)
JJ Wetherholt
The take Wetherholt got robbed, or glove-first rookie was overrated; fans split
The split in the crowd is the right reaction, because both sides have a number. His 4.6 fWAR led all NL rookies, built on 17 home runs and a +23 fielding run value at second. MLB.com calls the glove his calling card and the bat league-average. That is a real case. But he finished third with 99 points and three first-place votes, and his OPS fell from .755 before the break to .608 after, overlapping two weeks lost to wrist tendinitis. The all-in metric loved him. The ballots did not.
JJ Wetherholt cards on eBay →(paid link)
Tarik Skubal
The take Skubal is free agency's prize; every big spender is circling
Skubal is the one free agent everyone agrees on, and the reasons are sitting in plain view. He won his second straight AL Cy Young in 2025, the first back-to-back winner since Jacob deGrom in 2018-19, and the Dodgers traded three prospects to Detroit to get him at the Aug. 3 deadline. MLB.com calls him the crown jewel of the class. Where he lands is the only open question. The Dodgers hold the incumbent's advantage and the expectation that they will push to keep him. Detroit has his August remark that he would love to return, and goodwill counts for something. His $32 million arbitration salary, the highest ever awarded to a pitcher in that process, is the floor. The guess here is Los Angeles, because a club that shipped out three prospects for two months has already decided to keep him.
Tarik Skubal cards on eBay →(paid link)
The winter starts with one arm
Four of these five names are done. Two trophies, two near-misses, and a fan base in Queens with one runner-up finish and nothing else to show for the award cycle. The only story still in motion is Skubal. The Dodgers traded three prospects for two months of him and then watched the Brewers take the title. That is the kind of outcome that makes a front office either flinch or reach deeper. The bet here is reach. A club that ships out three prospects for a rental has already decided to keep him, and a back-to-back Cy Young winner does not reach the open market to take a discount.