Fever BaseballFor collectors and stat nerdsFuture Value Radar (FVR) · On the record

Fever Report No. 033 · 2026-10-09

The Drift

Jonny DeLuca moved four spots on the fade board this window — his results ran further ahead of a bat that's good but not this good.

The Rays are in October baseball and Jonny DeLuca is helping. The chatter says he's getting hits, making catches at the wall, doubling off the wall in the ALDS. A betting model hit on his over. Tampa Bay advanced past the Yankees and he's part of the reason. None of that is in dispute.

What's in dispute is whether the line is his, or whether he's borrowing.

This window, DeLuca moved up four spots on the fade board — No. 7 to No. 3. The engine's case on him didn't ease. It strengthened. His results ran further ahead of his contact, and the gap widened.

The person

He's a Thousand Oaks kid — Jonathan Davis DeLuca, born July 1998 — and the tools were visible early. As a freshman at Agoura High, coach Anthony Chevrier told DeLuca and his father the kid would play in the big leagues, even at a slight 5-foot-9. Chevrier would watch him dominate a track meet — he was a sprinter and long jumper, the son of a track athlete, with two older sisters who ran — then walk straight to baseball practice and hit. The prediction took nearly a decade to come true.

The Twins took him in the 39th round out of high school; he didn't sign. Oregon, then the Dodgers in the 25th round, pick 761, $300,000 to sign. In the minors, struggling at High-A in 2022, he bet himself he'd win Midwest League player of the week. He hit two homers that week and didn't win, so he walked into a Claire's and got his ear pierced. Then he tore off a .455 stretch, won back-to-back player of the week honors, got promoted, and the earring stayed.

Ryan Pepiot, who's known him since their shared 2019 draft class, calls him a goofball — the guy who showed up in New York wearing baggy linen pants and a sleeveless sweater. A surfer living on St. Pete Beach, knitting between games. The Dodgers sent both of them to Tampa Bay in December 2023 for Tyler Glasnow and Manuel Margot, and DeLuca found a home in right field.

He grinds. The speed plays — 29.3 ft/s. The defense plays. The question is the bat.

The signal

DeLuca's EV95 is 106.85 mph. He hits the ball harder than the average qualified MLB hitter. That is not nothing. But his results on contact are outrunning that bat, and the luck gap sits at 0.0814 — No. 3 of 15 on the fade board.

The kid who walked into a Claire's and came out with a pierced ear doesn't lack for belief. But belief doesn't close a luck gap. The bat is fine. The line is better than fine. The gap between them is the kind that closes from above. Across 112 games this season he's hit .266 with 11 home runs and a .729 OPS — a useful player, and the engine says the useful is leaning on luck.

His last three games — .333 with two home runs and a 1.218 OPS — are the gap running hot. That's playoff baseball. It's also exactly the shape the fade board is built to flag.

The read is PAID: his line has outrun his contact.

The market

His flagship rookie card — the 2024 Topps Chrome Rookie Autograph — sits at $3.99 raw and $40.69 in a PSA 10. The raw bounced between $2.99 and $4.16 over the last two months, bottoming in late August and climbing back through September as the Rays pushed for October. The PSA 10 is up 0.1% on the week — flat, essentially. The market hasn't noticed the drift. Playoff exposure could lift it further before the gap closes, or the gap could close first and the card won't care about October at all.

Jonny DeLuca cards on eBay →

Paid link — as an eBay Partner, FVR earns from qualifying purchases. Not financial advice. We take positions only after publication — never before. Misses stay on the record.

On the record

The fade case weakens when contact catches up to the line — when DeLuca's results stop outpacing what his bat supports. What would prove us wrong: his luck gap narrows from its current 0.0814 over a full sample next season, meaning his contact quality rose to meet his production. We'll know by next Opening Day.

Biographical details per the Los Angeles Times, Tampa Bay Times, The Acorn, and Wikipedia. All performance data: MLB StatsAPI via the FVR engine.

— FVR · misses stay on the record —