Fever BaseballFor collectors and stat nerdsFuture Value Radar (FVR) · On the record

The Buzz · November 12, 2026

The Buzz — Thursday, November 12

Awards season handed three pitchers their verdicts this week and put a fourth back on the trade block. Under each name, the number that says whether the take holds up.

Cam Schlittler

The take Yankees ace swept every vote; he's baseball's best young pitcher

The unanimous vote settles one argument and opens a bigger one. Every BBWAA ballot in the American League had Schlittler's name at the top, which means no writer looked at the field and found a second choice worth defending. That is not a close call. The number underneath the trophy is a 1.95 ERA across 33 starts, the lowest by a Yankees starter since Ron Guidry's 1.74 in 1978, and at 25 he is the youngest Yankee to win the award.

Since his July 9, 2025 debut, he owns a 2.23 ERA across 47 starts, the best in baseball over that span, tied for the most starts in the game. Aaron Boone called it as dominant a season as a pitcher can have, and the record says he was not reaching. The crowd says he is the best young pitcher alive, and the record does not argue back.

Cam Schlittler cards on eBay →(paid link)

Louis Varland

The take Blue Jays closer Varland wins brand-new BBWAA AL Reliever of the Year

A 1.27 ERA with 35 saves and 97 strikeouts is the line of a closer who did not give hitters a livable at-bat, and the BBWAA's first AL Reliever of the Year vote reflects that. The award is new. Varland is its first recipient, so the title carries novelty, but the numbers carry the weight.

The vote was closer than the stat line suggests. Varland got 16 of 30 first-place votes and 146 points to Cade Smith's 133. That is a bare majority of top ballots, not a runaway. But a 1.27 ERA is the gap between a reliever and a stopper, and the writers saw it.

Louis Varland cards on eBay →(paid link)

Jacob Misiorowski

The take Misiorowski, 24, is the unanimous NL Cy Young winner after Brewers' title

The vote was unanimous, and the season was more convincing than the vote. Misiorowski led baseball with a 1.80 ERA and 252 strikeouts. The innings were fewer than a classic workhorse carries, so the dominance is per-inning rather than volume-driven, a rate of damage that makes the distinction a footnote. He joined Verlander in 2019 and Pedro Martínez in 2000 as the only pitchers with 250-plus strikeouts and a WHIP as low as 0.80, and his 37.9% strikeout rate trails only Gerrit Cole's 2019 mark.

That company is the entire case. The Brewers won a franchise-record 103 games and their first World Series, and Misiorowski threw 5 2/3 shutout innings in the Game 5 clincher. He is the seventh pitcher to win a title-clinching game and a Cy Young in the same year. The ballots were cast before October, so the ring did not buy the award.

The one thread left is the 188 innings he carried into Game 5, regular and postseason combined, which had MLB.com writing his tank might be close to empty before he went out and threw zeroes. That is a workload flag for a 24-year-old in his first full season, not a health issue. What remains is how many innings that arm can carry before Milwaukee has to decide what to ask of it.

Jacob Misiorowski cards on eBay →(paid link)

Ketel Marte

The take Blue Jays circling Marte as Diamondbacks shop their drama-plagued star

The Blue Jays angle is a year old, a November 2025 TSN report citing Jon Morosi, resurfaced as if it were current. The actual news is Arizona shopping Marte after he did not show up for a series in Boston and was away from the club for roughly two weeks. His 2026 line was .249 with 22 home runs and a .748 OPS across 562 at-bats, a solid everyday regular rather than a collapse. He is on the block because the relationship broke, not because the bat did. With veto power over any trade, his list of acceptable destinations is the real constraint.

Ketel Marte cards on eBay →(paid link)

Where the winter actually bends

The three pitching awards are settled, unanimous or close, the ballots are in and the books are closed until spring. The live thread is Marte, because he is the first prominent name on the trade block who can refuse the move. Every suitor that calls Arizona has to answer a baseball question and then wait on a human one, and the second answer is the one nobody can forecast. The guess is he blocks any deal to a team he does not want, and Arizona spends the winter with a bat it cannot move and a relationship it cannot repair.

Trend signal from X. No fact is taken on a poster's word — every one is verified against and sourced from Associated Press (via NBC Sports), New York Post (via Yahoo Sports), The Bergen Record / NorthJersey.com (via Yahoo Sports), MLB.com, NBC Sports, ESPN, USA Today Sports (via Yahoo Sports). The Buzz comments; it never files a call.

Stats as of 2026-11-12.

Paid link — as an eBay Partner, FVR earns from qualifying purchases. Card links open an eBay search, not a listing — we hold no inventory.